Upon the Altar of the Nation: A Moral History of the Civil War

By Harry S. Stout

A well timed reconsideration of "just war," this landmark historical past heavily examines the ethical underpinnings of the struggle among the States

whilst the state tore itself aside through the Civil struggle, the North and the South marched below the banner of God. but the real ethical elements of this struggle have bought little observe from historians of the interval. during this gripping quantity, Yale spiritual historian Harry S. Stout demonstrates how either teams’ claims they had God on their part fueled the ferocity of the clash and its enduring legacy this present day.

continuing chronologically from the election of Lincoln to the beginning of Reconstruction, Stout explores how the basic ethical behavior of the conflict shifted from a restricted clash fought over constitutional concerns to a complete battle within which slaughter either off and on the battlefield was once justified because the simply skill to unconditional victory. As North and South alike enshrined their explanations as sacred, a type of nationwide faith emerged according to martyrdom and rebirth via violence.

Drawing on a desirable array of Civil warfare letters, sermons, editorials, diaries, and conflict images, Stout finds how women and men have been ensnared within the time’s patriotic propaganda and ideological grip and the way those wartime regulations proceed to echo within the debates at the present time. certain to galvanize an enormous reevaluation of this bloody and tormented interval and entice readers of James McPherson, Garry Wills, and David Herbert Donald, Upon the Altar of the Nation is a provocative and magnificent exam of rationale and behavior, either off and on the battlefield.

Show description

Quick preview of Upon the Altar of the Nation: A Moral History of the Civil War PDF

Best American Civil War books


“The maximum of our Civil battle novels” (New York instances) reissued for a brand new new release because the usa prepares to commemorate the Civil War’s one hundred and fiftieth anniversary, Plume reissues the Pulitzer Prize–winning novel broadly considered as the main robust ever written approximately our nation’s bloodiest clash.

Manet and the American Civil War: The Battle of U.S.S Kearsarge and C.S.S. Alabama

A examine of The Metropolitan Museum of Art's acquisition, "The "Kearsarge" at Boulogne", by way of Edouard Manet (1832-1883). through the American Civil struggle, whilst Union forces blocked accomplice ports, the Confederacy countered via waging guerrilla conflict on Union service provider delivery. essentially the most expert accomplice raiders was once the sloop-of-war "Alabama".

Gettysburg: The Last Invasion (Vintage Civil War Library)

Winner of the Guggenheim-Lehrman Prize in army HistoryAn Economist top ebook of the YearA Kirkus stories top Nonfiction ebook of the YearThe conflict of Gettysburg has been written approximately at size and carefully dissected when it comes to strategic significance, yet by no means prior to has a booklet taken readers so with regards to the event of the person soldier.

The Civil War Trilogy: Gods and Generals / The Killer Angels / The Last Full Measure

Michael Shaara reinvented the warfare novel together with his Pulitzer Prize–winning masterpiece of Gettysburg, The Killer Angels. Jeff Shaara persisted his father’s legacy with a chain of centuries-spanning ny instances bestsellers. This quantity assembles 3 Civil warfare novels from America’s first kin of army fiction: Gods and Generals, The Killer Angels, and The final complete degree.

Extra info for Upon the Altar of the Nation: A Moral History of the Civil War

Show sample text content

Marines below the Mexican struggle hero Robert E. Lee simply captured Brown and killed ten of his raiding get together. At his striking, Brown turned the contested image of America’s relentless march to violence. Northern abolitionists deemed Brown a freedom fighter whose execution rendered him a “martyr. ” within the view of white Southerners, Brown was once a fanatical terrorist who embodied the essence of the “Black Republican” social gathering. John Brown’s raid aroused a surprising tempest on the usa army Academy. West aspect, the nursery of America’s army leaders, was once destined to play a determinative function in shaping men’s minds within the Civil battle. Many Southern cadets erupted into violent ardour, denouncing the abolitionists and everybody within the North who both shared abolitionist perspectives or supported the Republican occasion. Passions boiled over whilst it used to be published former cadet, George W. Turner (class of 1831), on the time a farmer in Jefferson County, Virginia, was once killed during Brown’s raid. three On a chilly December evening in 1859, the main well-known fistfight in West aspect heritage broke out. Cadet Emory Upton—a self-defined “abolitionist” from Oberlin collage who was once “shocked” on the profanity he encountered at West Point—took offense whilst Wade Hampton Gibbs of South Carolina cheered Brown’s execution. Abolitionists have been few and much among at West aspect, yet Upton and a small crew of sympathizers met for weekly prayer conferences coordinated via the librarian, Oliver Otis Howard. while Upton introduced his perspectives to Gibbs, the Southern cadet replied along with his fists. Fellow cadets understood “the nationwide importance of the affair” without delay and crammed the corridor to spur on their respective pugilists. either cadets emerged badly bloodied yet unbowed. four On February 27, 1860, Lincoln added a lecture at Cooper Union in long island that he later defined as his most vital speech. the explanations are transparent. For Northern Republicans, Lincoln declared his antislavery sentiments and provided compelling ancient facts to set up (I) that the Framers of the structure have been, ordinarily, antislavery; (2) that they tolerated slavery simply with the knowledge that it might be extinguished over the years; and (3) that the government surely loved the ability to disclaim slavery in federal territories sooner than they turned states. In different phrases, the Dred Scott decision—not the Republican Party’s antislavery platform—was unconstitutional. in addition, the “peculiar establishment” itself was once improper. To extend slavery into the territories will be a denial that there has been something morally questionable approximately it. This, Lincoln hastened so as to add, didn't suggest that slavery as a result needed to be extirpated via strength the place it already existed. Nor did it justify the planned cultivation of slave insurrections. To the South, Lincoln made transparent his detestation of John Brown and his terrorist strategies: “John Brown used to be no Republican; and you have got did not implicate a unmarried Republican in his Harper’s Ferry company.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.45 of 5 – based on 47 votes