Haunted by Atrocity: Civil War Prisons in American Memory (Making the Modern South)

By Benjamin G. Cloyd

During the Civil conflict, nearly 56,000 Union and accomplice infantrymen died in enemy army legal camps. Even in the middle of the war's surprising violence, the depth of the prisoners' pain and the brutal demeanour in their deaths provoked outrage, and either the Lincoln and Davis administrations manipulated the felony controversy to serve the exigencies of conflict. As each side dispensed propaganda designed to persuade voters of every part of the relative advantage in their personal felony process -- unlike the tough inhumanity of the opponent -- they etched hardened and divisive stories of the felony controversy into the yank psyche, thoughts that might turn out tricky to uproot. In Haunted through Atrocity, Benjamin G. Cloyd deftly analyzes how american citizens have remembered the army prisons of the Civil conflict from the warfare itself to the current, creating a powerful case for the continuing value of the good clash in modern America.

Throughout Reconstruction and good into the 20 th century, Cloyd exhibits, competing sectional stories of the prisons lengthy the method of nationwide reconciliation. occasions akin to the trial and execution of CSA Captain Henry Wirz -- commander of the infamous Andersonville legal -- besides political campaigns, the booklet of felony memoirs, or even the development of monuments to the felony lifeless all revived the painful accusations of planned cruelty. As northerners, white southerners, and African americans contested the that means of the battle, those divisive stories tore on the scars of the clash and ensured that the topic of Civil battle prisons remained controversial.

By the Nineteen Twenties, the dying of the Civil warfare iteration got rid of a lot of the emotional connection to the struggle, and the devastation of the 1st international wars supplied new contexts within which to re-evaluate the which means of atrocity. for this reason, Cloyd explains, a extra target opinion of Civil warfare prisons emerged -- person who condemned either the Union and the Confederacy for his or her callous dealing with of captives whereas it deemed the mistreatment of prisoners an inevitable end result of contemporary struggle. yet, Cloyd argues, those seductive arguments additionally deflected a better exam of the fitting accountability for the tragedy of Civil warfare prisons and allowed american citizens to think in a comforting yet ahistorical reminiscence of the talk. either the recasting of the city of Andersonville as a Civil conflict village within the Nineteen Seventies and the 1998 beginning of the nationwide Prisoner of conflict Museum at Andersonville nationwide historical website display the continuing American choice for fantasy over heritage -- a choice, Cloyd asserts, that inhibits a candid review of the evils devoted throughout the Civil War.

The first learn of Civil struggle reminiscence to concentration solely at the army criminal camps, Haunted by means of Atrocity bargains a cautionary story of ways american citizens, for generations, have unconsciously developed their reminiscences of painful occasions in ways in which guard adored beliefs of delusion, that means, id, and, eventually, a deeply rooted religion in American exceptionalism.

Show description

Preview of Haunted by Atrocity: Civil War Prisons in American Memory (Making the Modern South) PDF

Best American Civil War books


“The maximum of our Civil struggle novels” (New York occasions) reissued for a brand new new release because the usa prepares to commemorate the Civil War’s a hundred and fiftieth anniversary, Plume reissues the Pulitzer Prize–winning novel broadly considered as the main robust ever written approximately our nation’s bloodiest clash.

Manet and the American Civil War: The Battle of U.S.S Kearsarge and C.S.S. Alabama

A research of The Metropolitan Museum of Art's acquisition, "The "Kearsarge" at Boulogne", via Edouard Manet (1832-1883). throughout the American Civil battle, while Union forces blocked accomplice ports, the Confederacy countered via waging guerrilla conflict on Union service provider delivery. some of the most expert accomplice raiders used to be the sloop-of-war "Alabama".

Gettysburg: The Last Invasion (Vintage Civil War Library)

Winner of the Guggenheim-Lehrman Prize in army HistoryAn Economist top publication of the YearA Kirkus studies top Nonfiction e-book of the YearThe conflict of Gettysburg has been written approximately at size and carefully dissected by way of strategic value, yet by no means ahead of has a e-book taken readers so on the subject of the event of the person soldier.

The Civil War Trilogy: Gods and Generals / The Killer Angels / The Last Full Measure

Michael Shaara reinvented the warfare novel together with his Pulitzer Prize–winning masterpiece of Gettysburg, The Killer Angels. Jeff Shaara persisted his father’s legacy with a sequence of centuries-spanning long island occasions bestsellers. This quantity assembles 3 Civil warfare novels from America’s first relatives of army fiction: Gods and Generals, The Killer Angels, and The final complete degree.

Extra resources for Haunted by Atrocity: Civil War Prisons in American Memory (Making the Modern South)

Show sample text content

Indicated the ongoing centrality of the criminal factor for the Union veterans and the Republican celebration. “It is on the door of the Recrimination in the course of Reconstructionâ•… forty five accomplice govt I lay the cost of wanton and savage cruelty to helpless prisoners of war,” Shanks thundered, ahead of invoking the sympathies of the viewers: “I might, if i'll, name sooner than your imaginations the gaunt, spectral kinds of these millions of robbed, frozen, starved, overwhelmed, wounded, manacled, dogged, emaciated, missed, crazed, and murdered males. ”48 Shanks’s oration testified to either the long-lasting strength of the vitriol over the remedy of prisoners and the recognition of the simple political capital won from recycling outdated allegations. The preeminence of Union veterans within the Republican get together, as evidenced by means of the next elections of supply, Rutherford Hayes, and James Garfield to the presidency, intended a normal specialize in what top certified them for public office—meritorious carrier to the Union reason. It additionally intended that the symbolic factor of Civil battle prisons persevered to be invoked via Republican politicians at any time when handy. Repetitious point out of the accusations of accomplice atrocity, the party of the sacrifice of the Union prisoners’ bravery, and the innocence of the Union govt all contributed to a political phenomenon referred to as “waving the bloody blouse. ”49 The 1872 reelection of furnish once more validated the sturdy strength of the reminiscence of Civil conflict prisons to encourage righteousness within the North. On September 21, 1872, a Thomas Nast comic strip in Harper’s Weekly conjured up the outdated animosity over the stipulations at Andersonville. Presidential candidate Horace Greeley, a Democrat, stood, with hand outstretched to the South, whereas lower than him lay the sizeable stockade of Andersonville, jam-packed with graves. Nast juxtaposed Greeley’s quote “Let us clasp arms over the bloodiest chasm” with an indication that includes a cranium and crossbones that said “Andersonville legal. Who Ever Entered right here Left wish in the back of. ”50 Nast’s atmosphere proved telling. rather than a battlefield resembling Gettysburg or Antietam, of the bloodiest battles of the conflict, Nast selected Andersonville to symbolize “the bloodiest chasm” of the Civil struggle. That selection reflected the preferred northern belief of Andersonville as a bad anomaly, the results of demonic, planned cruelty. In a political tradition nonetheless infected via the paradoxical have to either have fun and hate, Nast expertly conveyed the message complete reconciliation with the South used to be very unlikely and finally bad at the present, given the horrors skilled at Andersonville. to prevent that reconciliation, northerners had to proceed to vote Republican until eventually the southern penance of Reconstruction was once deemed whole. Undeniably powerful as a realistic political tactic, the power use of a 46â•… Haunted via Atrocity one-sided reminiscence of Civil conflict prisons, with its emphasis at the evils of the Confederacy and the purity of the Union, benefited Republican politicians in one other, much less tangible way—it enabled northerners to disregard the same reports accomplice prisoners persisted within the North.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.72 of 5 – based on 4 votes